Puppy Mills: The reality (courtesy of Main Line Animal Rescue)Last Friday, dog lovers from our area tuned into Oprah, even those of us who are not regular Oprah aficionados. Why? Because Bill Smith, a leader in dog rescue and founder of
Main Line Animal Rescue, did a daring thing:
He posted a billboard:

Oprah, a known dog lover, noticed, and did a show on
on Main Line Animal Rescue and Puppy Mills. (The show also included a tear jerking, amazing tribute to her dog Sophie who passed away)
Here is what she
said:Just before Sophie passed away, Oprah—and thousands of drivers—saw a billboard just off the Kennedy Expressway in Chicago that read, "Oprah: Do a show on puppy mills. The dogs need you."
The man behind the billboard is Bill Smith, founder of Main Line Animal Rescue. Every year, Bill and several volunteers rescue hundreds of abused, unwanted or abandoned animals, rehabilitate them and adopt them out to families. Many of the animals Bill rescues come from puppy mills, which he describes as places where bad breeders care more about the profit they make from puppies than the health or welfare of the animals. He says the dogs in puppy mills face deplorable conditions including inbreeding, minimal or no vet care, limited shelter and overcrowded cages.
"We were so frustrated … and no one seemed to be helping them," Bill tells Oprah. "I know that you're a huge animal lover. I just thought that you would be able to spread the word and educate a lot of people."
The billboard certainly worked. "It is my belief that when you actually see this, America, with your own eyes," Oprah says, "that you are not going stand for it."
Amen, Oprah....and shame on people like
who have been web dripping with drivel like "Oprah After Breeders Says American Sporting Dog Alliance "It's all very convenient in my mind, because some breeders do not like Puppy Lemon Laws, and feel it interferes in their business practices. To them I say, if you are doing everything above board, why do you worry? Why do you have to worry? The point of animal advocacy is to raise awareness, and these selfless dog rescuers can do their part, but the rest of us must do ours as well - one thing is to push Gov. Ed Rendell and PA to enforce the laws on the books.
Another post I discovered
from KC DOG BLOG says:
More follow-up Oprah
Caveat has an excellent post today. Some words from John Yates of the American Sporting Dog Alliance.
The post is pretty long - -but well worth the read. It asks a lot of the tough questions that weren't gotten into on the show.
I've noted that overall, I was a fan of the program. I think it created awareness of a problem that many of us have known about for way too long. However, it wasn't an in-depth, ask the hard questions sort of report. Yates' comments are.
I did find parts of
this post from the aforementioned John Yates pretty darn offensive when he says:
Dog Owners’ Oprah Alert by JOHN YATES The American Sporting Dog Alliance http://www.americansportingdogalliance.org Dog owners might be in for another bashing on Friday, when ultra-liberal talk show host Oprah Winfrey does a special program on “puppy mills.” Winfrey’s star reporter, Lisa Ling, went undercover in commercial breeding kennels to do an expose on the pet store trade. Although the commercial trade in pet store puppies has nothing to do with the vast majority of dog owners and breeders, sensationalistic news coverage tars us with the same brush. To the liberal animal rights mindset, all breeders are either “puppy mills” or “backyard breeders,” and this always translates into more laws that harm only the innocent. Moreover, the hidden agenda of the animal rights movement is the ultimate elimination of animal ownership, and their strategy is to pick us off one group at a time....On Friday, we can expect a thumping with no opportunity to defend ourselves. The Winfrey/Ling style of journalism is to exploit highly emotional topics and sensationalize them to twang the heartstrings of a predominantly middle class audience of liberals who are looking for the next “do-gooder” cause to embrace. It looks like saving the whales or feeding starving people in Somalia aren’t fashionable this year. Pity the poor whales. Pity the poor Somali refugees. And pity the poor dog owners!
A campaign against dog owners and breeders has become the latest fashionable cause for the glitz and glitter crowd of celebrities.....I think we can do it, if we get off of our butts and actually do it. There are hundreds of thousands of people who breed dogs because they love them – show dogs, performing dogs, hunting dogs, obedience dogs, field trial dogs, companion dogs and just plain dogs. In addition, there are millions of dog owners who love their animals and thank breeders for doing the fine job that they know we do in improving temperament, genetic soundness, utility, beauty and health. If we join together in this, we can be a formidable force. My thoughts are that a boycott of Winfrey’s advertisers would be the most effective strategy. If several hundred thousand dog owners and breeders were to contact advertisers on the Oprah show and refuse to buy any of their products, they would be forced to take notice...The American Sporting Dog Alliance is asking all dog owners and breeders to watch the Oprah Show on Friday and form your own opinions. Then, if she does the kind of hatchet job we expect, please bombard her with emails expressing your displeasure.
John Yates, you are totally missing the point and have your own selfish motives no doubt. No one is targeting responsible dog owners and dog breeders. And lemme ask John Yates a question: Can you sleep at night with the tactics that you and your pals are taking: because fess up, you aren't
just targeting Oprah, are you? Is it not true that your little robots are also targeting the selfless volunteers at Main Line Animal Rescue with vitriolic e-mails, etc? What are you so afraid of? That Main Line Rescue is actually
doing something? See this is why so many bad breeders still can remain in business - because of have to be right or die types like these sporting dog alliance folks.
And that dear readers is bull sheit.I think people everywhere should boycott the
American Sporting Dog Alliance for their selfish, obstreperous behavior, and how would THEY feel?
Of course, two wrongs don't make a right, so IGNORE those people and look at the big picture: there are pets in crisis all over this country and they are in as sorry shape as some of our nation's children.
For other interesting posts on irresponsible breeders, etc, check out these two from Philly Future:
ANOTHER PA Dog Breeder violates Puppy Lemon Laws....Update on a dog post....And read this:
Posted on Fri, Apr 4, 2008
Main Line Animal Rescue watches Oprah appearance
By Laurie Perini, lperini@phoenixvillenews.com
PHOENIXVILLE — Many of Main Line Animal Rescue’s 85 volunteers were crowded in two rooms at the shelter to watch “Oprah” on Friday.
While many of them might be avid Oprah watchers, they gathered because Oprah featured Main Line Animal Rescue and founder William Smith on a show about puppy mills.
“It was a great show,” said Smith. “I think it turned out really well. It will educate people not only about puppy mills but about euthanasia.”
The show explained that many dogs in shelters must be euthanized because there is not enough room for them or they cannot be placed in homes. It also stressed the importance of getting pets spayed or neutered.
Main Line Animal Rescue volunteers got together with snacks and drinks and sat attentively whenever Oprah came back from commercials.
There was applause, combined gasps and even some members who had to turn away when the show focused on the dogs being euthanized.
Throughout the program, some volunteers were fielding phone calls from people who were watching the show and wanted more information.
The volunteers help make Main Line Animal Rescue a success, with one of the highest placement rates in the United States at 99 percent.
and
Stu Bykofsky: Local guy coaxed Oprah into show attacking puppy mills
By Stu Bykofsky
Philadelphia Daily News
Daily News Columnist
IF OPRAH CAN DO for Fido what she's done for some authors and Barack Obama, dog lovers will wag their tails. They were drooling in anticipation of Oprah's show last Friday.
Oprah's endorsement turns books you never heard of into best-sellers, and transforms lagging presidential hopefuls into odds-on contenders.
As a onetime TV columnist, then gossip columnist, I know that most celebrities are empty-headed clowns who don't have the humility to thank their lucky stars for making them winners in life's lotto.
Oprah is among the exceptions, and when America's most influential woman pushes an issue, Americans respond.
On her Friday show, a teary-eyed Oprah condemned puppy mills, the bitter betrayal of "man's best friend." The canine horror houses are located mostly in Oklahoma, Missouri - and the Puppy Mill Capital of the East, picturesque Lancaster County.
Given that Oprah is a dog lover - her coddled canines live better than you or I - she came late to the anti-puppy-mill party and only after a very public "invitation" by Bill Smith.
The founder and head of 10-year-old Main Line Animal Rescue, in Chester Springs, Smith in February spent $10,000 of a donor's money to put up an anti-puppy-mill billboard near Oprah's studio. It pictured a cute dog pleading: "Oprah - please do a show on puppy mills; the dogs need you."
Friday, the dog's wish came true.
An animal protector for 25 years, the 46-year-old Smith makes countless trips to Pennsylvania Dutch country to talk puppy-mill owners out of sick and old dogs, which would otherwise be shot. For most of these breeders, dogs are a cash crop, like cabbage or corn.
Please support groups like
Main Line Animal Rescue and the
ASPCA in their efforts to combat dog abusers in this country.
Our pets are members of our family, not merely a furry accessory or a
cash crop! Speaking of cash crop, read this from
PACashCrop:
We all know puppy mills are bad. Factory farms where thousands of breeding dogs are kept in cages slightly larger than their own bodies. Underfed dogs feeding an industry of corruption and greed. Instead of walking on grass, they stand a lifetime on stretched wire flooring in cramp rabbit hutches. Instead of collars or bandannas, they wear rusted livestock clips in their ears or chains with USDA tags embedded in their necks. Undeserving of a name after eight years of service, a breeding female is often led into a dark cornfield and killed once she can no longer produce her young for market. Puppies who fail to sell often share the same fate. Unable to compete with the newest litters of seven week olds, they are destroyed at five or six or seven months of age. These little "left-over" puppies who grow too fast and lose their ability to bring in the top prices.
The factory farming of man's best friend is an ugly business. Each step of the process is harsh, inhumane and unspeakably cruel. The "extermination" of retired breeding dogs and unsold puppies is horrendous to anyone who loves dogs, and yet in Pennsylvania, it is perfectly legal. Dogs are "agricultural products" in our fair state and can be destroyed like any other livestock once they fail to turn a profit. Purchase a puppy bred in one of Pennsylvania's infamous puppy mills and you are supporting this inhumane practice. You are contributing to the cruelty. Remember, ninety-nine percent of the dogs sold in pet stores come from puppy mills.
Again, support
the ASPCA, and groups like
Main Line Rescue.Bill Smith, you are my hero, and the hero to many others like me. Thank you for your courage.